If you’re looking for a magical dessert that’s easy, colorful, and kid-approved, this Unicorn Trifle Recipe is pure party perfection! With layers of teal, purple, and pink Cool Whip nestled between chunks of Trader Joe’s blondies and bits of toffee bar crunch, it’s a whimsical treat that doubles as the centerpiece of your unicorn-themed party.
This no-bake dessert is as fun to make as it is to eat — and with only three simple ingredients (plus a few decorative touches), it’s a guaranteed hit for little bakers, busy parents, and anyone who believes in a little kitchen magic.
✨ Why You’ll Love This Unicorn Dessert
Just 3 main ingredients! Simple, affordable, and mess-free.
No baking required — perfect for last-minute birthdays or playdates.
Toddler-approved — kids love layering the pastel Cool Whip clouds!
Looks magical — the pastel layers and unicorn horn make it camera-ready for Pinterest-perfect parties.
🦄 Ingredients
You’ll need:
Trader Joe’s Blondies (or any blondie or cookie bar)
Heath / Toffee Bars, crushed
Cool Whip, divided into three bowls
For decorating:
Pink food coloring (for marshmallow ears)
Mini marshmallows
Sugar cone or crystal ornament (for the horn)
Black paper or icing eyelashes
🌈 How to Make a Unicorn Trifle
Step 1: Prep Your Layers
Cut blondies into small cubes. Crush Heath bars into small crumbles. Divide Cool Whip into three bowls and tint each with pastel teal, purple, and pink food coloring.
Step 2: Build Your Trifle
In a clear trifle dish:
Add a layer of blondie cubes.
Spoon on a layer of teal Cool Whip.
Sprinkle toffee crumbles on top.
Add another layer of blondie cubes, followed by purple Cool Whip, and more toffee.
Finish with pink Cool Whip on top and a final sprinkle of toffee.
Step 3: Add the Unicorn Magic
Create unicorn ears by painting large square marshmallows with pink food coloring. I cut them in half diagonally to get the ear shape. Place them on top of your trifle along with a sugar cone or crystal ornament as the horn.
Add black eyelashes using icing or paper cutouts to give your trifle its adorable unicorn face. I used some eye lash stickers, but you can also draw them on with dry erase marker.
🎨 Make It Yours
Rainbow twist: Add more colors to your Cool Whip for a full rainbow trifle.
Mini versions: Serve in small clear cups for individual unicorn trifles — perfect for birthday party tables!
Toddler fun: Let little ones build their own — it’s a great way to combine fine motor skills with creative play.
💡 Sensory Play Meets Dessert
This unicorn trifle isn’t just a sweet treat — it’s a multi-sensory experience. Kids can touch, scoop, layer, and color, engaging their senses while building independence and creativity. The textures of the Cool Whip, the crunch of toffee, and the soft blondies make it a perfect taste-safe sensory play activity turned dessert.
🩷 Pin This for Later
Whether it’s a unicorn birthday, pastel tea party, or just a cozy weekend bake-together, this Unicorn Trifle will bring instant smiles — and maybe a few happy sprinkles along the way.
📌 Save this idea for your next magical moment!
✨ More Unicorn Birthday Party Ideas
If you loved this magical idea, keep the unicorn fun going with even more whimsical treats and crafts from our Unicorn Birthday Party Collection! Each one is simple, colorful, and perfect for creating a birthday your little one will never forget.
🦄 Unicorn Birthday Party Ideas – Our ultimate guide to hosting the perfect unicorn-themed celebration!
🍿 Unicorn Popcorn Balls – Sweet, crunchy, and covered in pink, purple, and teal sprinkles—perfect for little hands to help make.
🍨 Unicorn Trifle – Layers of pastel whipped cream, toffee bits, and blondie crumbles make this dessert a total showstopper.
🍦 Unicorn Frozen Yogurt Pops – A healthy, refreshing snack that’s just as magical as it looks.
🧁 Unicorn Pudding Cups – An easy, no-bake dessert that’s bursting with color and creamy flavor.
🍋 Unicorn Lemonade – The prettiest drink for your unicorn party table—swirls of pink, purple, and sparkle!
🍝 Unicorn Pasta – A magical mealtime idea with colorful noodles that bring joy to every bite.
🍬 Unicorn Bark – A sweet and simple candy treat topped with sprinkles and glittery magic.
💖 Unicorn Painting Craft – A creative art project that lets kids design and style their own ceramic unicorns